Pride Month came to a sad end with a ruling from the Supreme Court allowing businesses to refuse services to LGBTQ+ individuals based on religious objections.
We’ve seen this before – religion being used as an excuse to discriminate.
In 1968 the Supreme Court heard a case from South Carolina in which a white supremacist, Maurice Bessinger, who ran a chain of Piggie Park Bar-B-Q restaurants, refused service to a black man, John W. Mungin, because he believed the races should be strictly segregated. Mungin claimed the action was in violation of the recently passed Civil Rights Act (1964). The store owner invoked a higher law – God’s – or, should I say, “His view of God’s law.”?
Here’s what Bessinger’s lawyers wrote in answer to Mungin’s complaint:
“Bessinger believes as a matter of faith that racial intermixing or any contribution thereto contravenes the will of God.”
Does anyone really think now that Bessinger was right then – that following God allows us, even compels us, to discriminate against other races?
Yes, sadly, some do.
Gladly, most don’t.
1968 was 55 years ago. The Justices in that case, unanimous in their ruling against Piggie Park, called the religious freedom defense for the race-based denial of service, “patently frivolous,” and ordered Bessinger to pay Mungin’s attorneys’ fees.
We obviously have a different SCOTUS today.
But we have the same prejudices – just toward another group.
In 2078, 55 years from now, will Americans look back on today’s court decision, on today’s anti-LGBTQ+ attitudes and wonder, “How could we have thought that?”
We got the Bible wrong in 1968.
We got God wrong in 1968.
Maybe we are getting them wrong today.
Fr Richard Rohr explains that the core and call of religion (re-ligio) is to “re-ligament” us. Instead of using religion to divide and discriminate, let’s use it in these “United” States to actually unite, providing “liberty and justice for all.”